Month: March 2024
Healing on the Sabbath: A Thought on the Mystery of Holy Saturday
Deacon Douglas McManaman
Christ heals on the sabbath. But isn’t the sabbath rest a symbol of eternity? We are in the 6th day, the day on which God created man in the image of himself (Gn 1, 26-31). In fact, all of human history is the 6th day, and the days prior to this day (days 1 to 5) represent the evolution of the universe and the world, leading up to the 6th day. When history comes to an end, when man’s work is done, we enter into the 7th day, the sabbath rest, or God’s rest (Heb 4, 10). But Jesus says: “My Father is still working, and I also am working” (Jn 5, 16-30).
The Father is unchanging activity, and activity and rest coincide in God. He does not stop working on the sabbath, and neither does the Son. Even in eternity, of which the sabbath day is a symbol, God is unchanging activity (contemplation). He is still saviour, and his Son is saviour (Jesus: “Yahweh is salvation”), because whatever the Father does, the Son does: “The Son can do nothing on his own, but only what he sees the Father doing” (Jn 5, 19). And so, the Son heals on the sabbath. Is not this a mirror reflection of what will continue in the eternal (aionios) sabbath? The Greek word ‘aionios’ does not mean eternal in the sense of ‘never ending’, but ‘other worldly’ (not this temporal world, but where God dwells), or ‘ages of ages’. In Christ, eternity is joined to the world of matter and time.
But who needs healing on the aionios sabbath? The forsaken do. Just as in the time of Christ on earth, the sick, the lame, and the poor were regarded as forsaken by God, in the aionios sabbath, there are those who “rise to their condemnation” (Jn 5, 29), because they did not believe in the Son of Man. Are they not the object of the divine mercy? They are indeed because they are the object of his justice, and the divine justice has been revealed as mercy. Does God, who is unchanging, suddenly change after the 6th day? Divine chastisement (kolasis) must, if it be truly a chastisement, come to an end; it cannot be forever–no one prunes a plant forever, for there would be nothing left. Pruning (kolasis) takes place for the good of the plant.
Jesus came not to condemn the world, but that the world may have life through him, but some will rise to their condemnation. This condemnation is not the final word, rather, life has the final word: “I say to you, the hour is coming and is now here when the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear will live” (Jn 5, 25). Holy Saturday is the realization of this promise. Christ descended into hell, as we profess in the creed (the word ‘dead’ was changed to ‘hell’ in the Roman liturgy). What does Christ do in hell? He is himself in hell, that is, he is “Jesus” (Yahweh is salvation); he is life. He does what he sees the Father doing–he proclaims the good news of salvation, and he freed all who were imprisoned therein:
Death, unwilling to be defeated, is defeated; corruption is transformed; unconquerable passion is destroyed. While hell, diseased with excessive insatiability and never satisfied with the dead, is taught, even if against its will, that which it could not learn previously. For it not only ceases to claim those who are still to fall [in the future], but also sets free those already captured, being subjected to splendid devastation by the power of our Saviour.… Having preached to the spirits in hell, once disobedient, he came out as conqueror by resurrecting his temple like a beginning of our hope, and by showing to [our] nature the manner of the raising from the dead, and giving us along with it other blessings as well (Cyril of Alexandria, Fifth Festive Letter, 29–40 (SC 372, 284). Quoted in Metropolitan Hilarion Alfeyev, Christ the Conqueror of Hell, p. 78).
Does God turn his back on anyone, even on those who reject him? Certainly not forever: “The Lord’s acts of mercy are not exhausted, his compassion is not spent; They are renewed each morning–great is your faithfulness… For the Lord does not reject forever (Lam 3, 22-23; 31).
Christ’s Redemption: An Explanation for Teachers
https://www.lifeissues.net/writers/mcm/mcm_407dchristredemptionforteachers.html
Deacon Douglas McManaman
The word ‘redemption’ comes from the verb ‘to redeem’, as in to buy back, to repurchase at a price. In the context of the Old Testament, redemption is the deliverance of Israel from Egyptian slavery. Christ is redeemer, and this means that just as through Moses, God delivered the covenant people of Israel from Egyptian slavery, Jesus delivered humanity from the slavery of sin and its consequences, namely death. What was the means of exchange through which he bought us back? His own blood, that is, his life.
But what exactly does this mean? How does this work exactly? As a teacher, I was inclined to employ a “quantitative” or juridical model to explain this to adolescents, one that has its roots in St. Anselm. The reason is that the adolescent mind finds this easy to grasp, and making sense out of mystery is attractive to them. The basic idea is that sin creates an infinite debt, that is, a debt of infinite weight, and man, who is finite, cannot make up for a sin that is of infinite gravity or weight. Only God can do so. But God is not in debt–we are, and so it is up to man to make reparation for his sin, not God. But man cannot do so, because everything he offers is of finite value. Since man cannot make reparation, he simply cannot save himself. In short, our situation is hopeless.
God, however, provides a solution. The second Person of the Trinity joins a human nature; Jesus is fully God and fully man, two natures, one Person. As man, he can go before the Father and offer a sacrifice of reparation on our behalf; as God the Son, his offering has infinite value and can cancel our debt.
This is an attractive way of explaining Christ’s redemption, because it “makes sense” out of what is otherwise profoundly mysterious. Although some of what is said within this model has some truth, it is, however, a deficient model. It is far too juridical, and mystery really cannot be explicated using such narrow terms without serious consequences.
It is indeed the case that man is a slave to sin. Just as we inherit talents and dispositions from our parents or distant relatives, not to mention trauma undergone by relatives three or so generations back, we also inherit negative proclivities and sinful dispositions. This is what is meant by the wound of Original Sin called concupiscence–an inclination to sin and self-seeking. What this underscores among other things is man’s profoundly social nature. Original Sin is an inherited addiction, a proclivity. The first parents of the human race made a radical decision to be their own god, sufficient unto themselves (symbolized in the image of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil that stands independent and tall). We are the offspring of the first parents, and we are born into a concrete and universal situation they created. We are affected by their sin. We are born into a situation characterized by the loss of interior grace; for man was originally created in a state of grace, in the state of original justice (with the gift of bodily immortality, freedom from concupiscence, and a sense of the divine rooted in grace). We are not born “deified” by grace, and so we are deprived of the light of grace. We cannot free ourselves from that proclivity to sin and self-seeking, for it is a genuine slavery, and no slave can free himself or herself–otherwise it is not slavery.
But God the Son drew close to us. He joined a human nature to himself and dwelt among us. The light entered into the darkness:
For God did not send his Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world might be saved through him. Whoever believes in him will not be condemned, but whoever does not believe has already been condemned, because he has not believed in the name of the only Son of God. And this is the verdict, that the light came into the world, but people preferred darkness to light, because their works were evil. For everyone who does wicked things hates the light and does not come toward the light, so that his works might not be exposed. But whoever lives the truth comes to the light, so that his works may be clearly seen as done in God (Jn 3, 17-21).
We crucified the Son of God. Christ is Light from Light, true God from true God, and so the light entered into the darkness of our death, injecting it with his light and life. He destroyed our death, making it a means to eternal life. In joining himself to a human nature, God the son joined himself to every man/woman, as it were. The Word (logos) is present at the deepest level of our being. This does not mean that we all exist in a state of sanctifying grace. Rather, he is there, and he offers us sufficient grace to move towards him, to allow him into our lives, to reign over our own mind and heart. His death was an offering to God the Father on our behalf, an act of religion, and his offering is an acceptable one, since it is a perfect offering, rooted in a perfect divine love for the Father and for us, who come from God.
Some years ago my daughter, my wife and I went to Italy with a friend of ours, who is Italian. And he took us north, and south, and in the middle, and my daughter loved it, and she was focused primarily on shopping. I hated going into shops to look for purses or dresses, I just wanted to explore the narrow streets and old churches. It was hot, always watching out for pickpockets, not enough time to visit the places I wanted to visit, so for me it was a very unpleasant trip. The following year, however, I had the opportunity to go again, this time without my wife and daughter, just a priest friend of mine and a good friend who is also a teacher. His parents own an apartment in Rome, so we spent two weeks there. What I found fascinating upon reflection was that I spent so much time visiting the fashion district, Via Del Corso, clothing shops, looking for purses, etc. I was doing a lot of shopping for my daughter, to bring things back for her, and I was enjoying it. I wanted to visit the places that she loved. I started to love these places, because there was something of her that was left behind. I couldn’t care less about the Trevi Fountain or the Spanish Steps, but because she loved those places, I had a very real desire to visit them again, but only because I was looking to recapture her presence. These places were dear to her, so they became dear to me.
I think this is a useful illustration of a profound theological truth. As was said above, God the Son joined a human nature to himself (Christ is two natures, but one Person). God the Son enters into human suffering because he loves the Father, desires his glory above all, and since we belong to God, he loves us and will not allow us to suffer alone. And that is why when God the Father sees humanity, he sees his Son. He delights in the individual human person because Christ does. The Father loves us because the Son loves us. “The kingdom of heaven is among you” means that the redemptive presence of the Second Person of the Trinity permeates this world, through the power of the reconciling Spirit.
We are redeemed by the Incarnation of the Son of God, by his entire life, which of course includes his death. God sees each one of us when he beholds his Son, and so the Son’s entire life and his offering of himself in the end redeems us, buys us back from darkness to light, from alienation from God to proximity to God in him, in Christ. And all of this was pure gift, pure grace. And so a better model for understanding something of our redemption is the story of Jesus’ encounter with Zacchaeus.
He came to Jericho and intended to pass through the town. Now a man there named Zacchaeus, who was a chief tax collector and also a wealthy man, was seeking to see who Jesus was; but he could not see him because of the crowd, for he was short in stature. So he ran ahead and climbed a sycamore tree in order to see Jesus, who was about to pass that way. When he reached the place, Jesus looked up and said to him, “Zacchaeus, come down quickly, for today I must stay at your house.” And he came down quickly and received him with joy. When they all saw this, they began to grumble, saying, “He has gone to stay at the house of a sinner.” But Zacchaeus stood there and said to the Lord, “Behold, half of my possessions, Lord, I shall give to the poor, and if I have extorted anything from anyone I shall repay it four times over.” And Jesus said to him, “Today salvation has come to this house because this man too is a descendant of Abraham. For the Son of Man has come to seek and to save what was lost” (Lk 19, 1-10).
Perhaps we can look at Zacchaeus as an image of humanity. He climbs the sycamore tree, as Adam (humanity) aspires to be more than what he is by eating from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. Jesus approaches Zacchaeus, not the other way around, and tells him to descend, for the Son of God descended and took the form of a slave, becoming obedient to death, death on a cross (Phil 2, 1-11). In Christ, we descend from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil and embrace our status as “children”, dependent upon God. Christ was not invited into Zacchaeus’ home; rather, he invited himself. And the result was a complete change of heart in Zacchaeus (metanoia). He was redeemed, bought back from the slavery of sin, all as a result of the approach of Christ.
Without the Incarnation, the suffering, death and resurrection of the Son of God, we would still be in our sins, still in darkness, still slaves of sin. We simply cannot save ourselves. Christ is savior. He came to save. And the gospel is a message of salvation. That is redemption.
We are a kingdom of priests
Deacon Douglas McManaman
We are a kingdom of priests @ Where Peter Is
The Word is living, being, spirit, all verdant greening, all creativity. This Word manifests itself in every creature. St. Hildegard of Bingen
I’d like to begin this reflection on the royal priesthood of the faithful with Paul’s letter to the Colossians:
He [Christ] is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of all creation. For in him were created all things in heaven and on earth, the visible and the invisible, whether thrones or dominions or principalities or powers; all things were created through him and for him (1, 15-16).
It is this last line in this text that is so important. All things were created for him, in view of him, for the sake of him. What this means is that everything finds its ultimate meaning in Christ, just as the meaning of anything is discovered in its final cause, its ultimate end. Christ is the ultimate meaning of creation, and since time is a part of creation, it follows that Christ is the ultimate meaning of history.
Christ is the Second Adam who sheds light on the very existence of the First Adam and his offspring (GS 22), revealing our original vocation. And what is that original vocation? The Epiphany sets us on a course to uncover it: a star led the Magi to the Christ child. This is fitting, because the cosmos exists through Christ and for Christ. The world that God created and sustains in existence, the cosmos in its entirety, is really an epiphany (manifestation). The created world manifests the divine; it speaks of God, of his divine generosity. It praises the beauty of God through its own proper beauty, and it speaks of the mind of God through its own order, inexhaustible intelligibility, and complexity. In Psalm 19, we read:
The heavens declare the glory of God; the firmament proclaims the works of his hands. Day unto day pours forth speech; night unto night whispers knowledge. There is no speech, no words; their voice is not heard; A report goes forth through all the earth, their messages, to the ends of the world. He has pitched a tent there for the sun; which comes forth like a bridegroom from his bridal chamber, and like a hero joyfully runs its course. From one end of the heavens it comes forth; its course runs through to the other; nothing escapes its heat (2-7).
In the prologue of the gospel of John, we read that the Word was made flesh and “set up his tent” among us (Greek: eskenosen, “booths”, “tabernacles”). The sun, mentioned in the psalm, is really a hierophany, a manifestation of the divine; for the ultimate meaning of the sun and its entire movement from one end of the sky to the other, is the very life of Christ the bridegroom, who made his tent among us and who is the light of the world, the true light that enlightens every person who comes into the world (1, 9). The sun is an image of the Son, the Logos, as is everything in the cosmos.
Everything in creation in some way (often hidden) announces, proclaims, speaks of the mystery of the Incarnation. Creation is language; it is full of words of the Word. More to the point, creation is a genuine liturgy, and like the liturgy of the new covenant it moves towards an end, which is communion, just as the six days of creation depict a movement towards the sabbath rest. The end of this liturgy of creation, of course, is communion with Christ.
Just as a work of art is in many ways an epiphany of the artist, revealing much about the artist, creation in all its diversity and complexity manifests and praises God. And the content of this manifestation becomes increasingly Trinitarian the closer we look. For example, light proceeds from the sun, but the light by which we see the sun cannot itself be seen. Similarly, the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Son, the second Person of the Trinity, but the third Person, like an invisible and formal sign, directs us immediately to the Son. As Sergei Bulgakov writes: “The hypostasis of the Spirit does not have its own Face, as it were, but is only the Face of the Son in His Glory….in the light of this Glory we can discern the glorified Face of the Logos-Christ, but not the proper Face of Glory itself” (The Comforter, translated by Boris Jakim, p. 188).
But there is more. In the first story of creation in Genesis, God says to man:
“Have dominion over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the air and over every living thing that moves upon the earth. I have given you every plant yielding seed which is upon the face of all the earth, and every tree with seed in its fruit; you shall have them for food” (1, 28-29).
In other words, God created the world as a banquet, to feed us. For the Jews, a meal is a source of communion with all those at table, because food is a source of life, and if we all partake of the same source from the same table, we become one life, one blood, one family. Thus, creation, which is given to man for food, is a source of communion with God.
Whatever God created, He created through the utterance of His Word, but to speak words is to communicate, and to communicate is to enter into communion. We speak in order to bring about a communion with the person we are addressing. And of course, God speaks all things into being, and so creation in all its diversity are words of the Word, uttered in order to bring about communion, in this case, communion with God.
Now a priest is one who offers sacrifice, in particular the sacrifice of thanksgiving. The word Eucharist is from the Greek eukharistia, which means “thanksgiving, gratitude”. Man’s task is to receive the food that is creation and give thanks for it, and we give thanks by blessing the giver. A blessing, however, is a benediction, and benediction, as the etymology of the word indicates, is the act of speaking well of something. God blesses each day of creation, for each day has its origin in a benediction: God said: “… Let there be …” God’s speaking is creative, effective, it brings into being, but what He brings into being blesses Him in return, that is, it speaks well of Him, as we see in the book of Daniel: “Sun and moon, bless the Lord; praise and exalt him above all forever. Stars of heaven, bless the Lord; praise and exalt him above all forever. Every shower and dew, bless the Lord; praise and exalt him above all forever. All you winds, bless the Lord…” (3, 62-65).
To bless is to receive what God gives, recognizing it for what it is, namely sheer gift. Of course, gratitude begins with such a recognition, and thanksgiving arises out of it. This recognition gives rise to a spirit of thanksgiving, or Eucharist. And since a priest is one who offers the sacrifice of thanksgiving, man was created to be a priest of creation–he was created to offer, to thank, to praise, to adore. We are to take what is given and raise it, lift it up to God, which involves a recognition of its origin. This raising up to God is benediction, blessing, a speaking well of…, and it is offered that it may become what God intended for it to become–namely, a means of communion with him.
This priestly pattern is visible at every level of creation. The lowest level of the hierarchy of being in the physical universe is the level of non-living matter, but non-living matter is food for the level above it, which consists of living things, i.e., plants, which take non-living matter and consume it, but in consuming it, plant life raises it up through the power of nutrition and transforms it into living matter (this is what happens when we water plants). But brute animals eat plants, and through the process of metabolism change plant life into living animal tissue, a higher mode of life. It does this, however, by killing it first and then raising it up. In other words, plants must be sacrificed first, that is, reduced to non-living matter, in order to be lifted up to serve something higher. Man exercises dominion over the animal kingdom, raising it up to serve human needs in a number of ways, not always for food (dogs can pull sleds, horses can pull carriages, as well as providing meat). But, when animals become food for man, the animal must first be slaughtered. And so, the communion of a meal is once again preceded and made possible through a sacrifice, a dying.
The rough details of this priesthood are there in the first two chapters of Genesis, in the command to creativity, to raise up creation to serve the needs of man, to cultivate the garden; moreover, we see it in the command to leave mother and father and cling to one another in the one flesh union of marriage. This “leaving” of mother and father receives its full significance in the paschal mystery, in Christ’s leaving of this world in order to go to the Father, as we read in the high priestly prayer of Christ (Jn 17, 1ff; Eph 5, 25-27).
Man, who is set apart (consecrated) from the rest of material creation in so far as he is created in the image and likeness of God, is to take all that he is and has become, and all that he possesses, and offer it to God, in the service of God, in a spirit of thanksgiving or Eucharist. In doing so, he offers to God the entire order of creation, which he contains within himself. Thus, man is a mediator between the cosmos and God, joining the two. In the first creation story, God is depicted as building a “house” (time, place, foundation, furnishings, etc.), but to build is to take raw materials and give them a new and elevated form, as in the creation of a house or work of art. And so, creativity has a priestly character to it. It emulates God, for the artist is speaking, communicating what he sees, and he is trying to speak well of what sees and admires. Genuine creativity is benediction, or blessing.
But the fall of man was a rejection of this priesthood. Adam chose to make himself his own god. As a result, he, including his offspring, the entire human race, gradually became deaf to the praises sung by creation; he no longer possessed the eyes and ears to understand the universe as an epiphany. And so, he no longer gave thanks. His life ceased to be Eucharistic; his life gradually ceased to be sacrificial. However, God made a covenant with Abraham, the father of Israel, in order to make her a holy nation, consecrated, that is, set apart from all others, a priestly people: “Now, if you obey me completely and keep my covenant, you will be my treasured possession among all peoples, though all the earth is mine. You will be to me a kingdom of priests, a holy nation” (Ex 19, 5-6).
The Word was made flesh in order to restore the world to its status as God’s kingdom (house, palace, covenanted family). Christ, who is God, is everything that the human person longs for, his kingdom is everything that the great religions of the world are seeking – namely, God become man. And what man was and is called to be is right there in the image of the Magi, priests of Persia, who begin a procession from the east, who follow the lead of a star, which leads them right to Christ, and they do homage to Christ. We were created “through him and for him”, ultimately for Christ’s priesthood, which we enter through baptism. We were created to worship, to adore, to offer; homo adorans expresses man’s deepest nature.
If we were created through him and for him, then we were created to become Christ, which is what happens in an ordinary Mass. Every day is to be a sacrifice of thanksgiving, a constant lifting up of all we have and are to God, to receive what the Lord gives us and to offer it to him in thanksgiving. This lifting up of what we have includes the lifting up of our work, our labor, which takes place throughout the six-day workweek, and this labor is a “building up”, a raising up, which includes the raising of our children, which is fundamentally a lifting up and an act of “building”. Every moment of our lives, every day of the six-day workweek, is to be an imitation of God in the act of creating, the act of blessing, and so each day is a benediction that we carry out. We bless God in the work we do; for in both creation stories, work is revealed as holy; in short, the work week is a priestly existence.
In baptism, this priestly identity, which is our deepest identity, is elevated and perfected, for we are anointed and thus made to participate in Christ’s priesthood: “He now anoints you with the chrism of salvation. As Christ was anointed Priest, Prophet, and King, so may you live always as a member of his body, sharing everlasting life” (Rite of Baptism for Infants). Thus, we are a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people of his own” (1 Pt 2, 9). In the book of Revelation, we read: “To him who loves us and has freed us from our sins by his blood, who has made us into a kingdom, priests for his God and Father, to him be glory and power forever and ever. Amen” (1, 5).
On the sabbath, we begin our procession as we leave the house and make our way to the altar. At the altar, we offer our sacrifices, our daily stresses and frustrations, all our efforts and the love behind that labor, and all this is represented in the bread and wine, which are universal signs of nourishment. They are food, the fruits of our labor, the matter of the earth. What the ordained ministerial priest does is he takes what we offer, that bread and wine, which is the fruit of our labor throughout the week, lifts it up on our behalf, and Christ, who is the priest at the altar, receives that bread and wine, the matter of creation, the food of creation that we have offered to him, and changes it into himself, his own body and blood, which in turn is the eternal sacrifice that the Son offers to the Father. And that is returned to us as food, but it is no longer bread and wine, but is precisely what the matter of this world is destined to become, namely the actual food of his body and blood: “For my body is real food”, he says, and “my blood real drink” (Jn 6, 55). The Eucharist is the completion of creation, and through it we are deified, united to the sacrificial offering of the Son to the Father, drawn into the intimate life of the Trinity.
And so, the ordained priesthood is ultimately at the service of the royal priesthood of the faithful. He is indeed set apart, but this does not mean a literal ‘being taken out of the world’, that is, an escape from the world, which characterizes Clichtove’s image of the priesthood; rather, the priest is to be set apart in the depths of his charity and humility, and his willingness to follow Christ, who emptied himself and entered into human suffering. By this kenotic life, the ministerial priest calls the faithful to an ever-deeper self-understanding and appreciation of the significance of this anointing, that is, their priestly, prophetic and royal identity.